Best Butt Plugs For Men – 2020 Review

As toys become part of the mainstream sexual culture, they become more versatile and user-friendly. While many men associate anal stimulation with sexual preference, nothing could be further from the truth. Straight men get as much pleasure from anal adventures as bisexual or gay men.

The butt plug is one of the simplest sex toys you can use, and it is a great introductory toy to the world of anal pleasure. They stimulate the nerves in the anus and the rectum through texture or vibration, and many are curved to provide prostate stimulation.

Comparison Chart of the Best Butt Plugs for Men

IMAGEPRODUCT
  • Stimulates perineum for double pleasure
  • Tapered tip for easy insertion
  • Silicone works with natural curves
View Latest Price →Read Customer Reviews
  • Plump insertable bulb
  • Remote control for creative play
  • 8 modes of vibration
View Latest Price →Read Customer Reviews
  • Tapered tip for extra stimulation
  • 2 speeds and 5 patterns
  • Great for intense internal massages
View Latest Price →Read Customer Reviews
  • 10 vibrating functions
  • Powerful, quiet and petite size
  • Ultra-flexible silicone base
View Latest Price →Read Customer Reviews
  • Angled tip for intense anal stimulation
  • Finger loop gives added control
  • Temperature responsive and hypoallergenic
View Latest Price →Read Customer Reviews

What Makes a Great Male Butt Plug?

Several factors make a great butt plug that will improve your overall experience.

Material

The most important factor in a male butt plug is the material. These toys come in several different materials, but only a few are suitable for anal use. Stay away from porous materials, such as TPR, jelly, and rubber. You cannot completely sanitize them, so they hold on to bacteria.

Always make sure that your toys are latex-free and phthalate-free. These materials can harm your body, causing allergic reactions and hormonal disruption. Phthalates – the chemical compound that gives jelly and plastic their flexibility – have been identified as carcinogens, so its best to avoid them.

The best butt plugs are made of nonporous materials such as silicone, metal, and glass. Silicone toys have a smooth, silky exterior. You can warm up or cool down metal and glass toys for some exciting temperature play. Silicone, glass, and metal toys are easier to clean, and they are safer for use in the most intimate parts of your body. They also feel much better!

Style

Although the terms “butt plug” and “prostate massager” are often used interchangeably, they are very different toys. Prostate massagers have a smooth curve – similar to G-spot toys for women – that targets the gland upon insertion. Butt plugs are for more general use, and they often lack the distinct curve of prostate massagers. Both toys are inserted and left in during use: prostate massagers mostly focus on stimulating the prostate, while butt plugs will pleasure the sensitive nerve endings at the beginning of the rectum.

Prostate massagers come in vibrating or non-vibrating options. A vibrating toy adds extra stimulation to the nerves in the rectum and the anus for more pleasurable prostate play. Many vibrating butt plugs have different speeds and functions, so you can find the one that is most satisfying for you.

When choosing a butt plug or a prostate massager, ALWAYS make sure it has a defined anchor. This part of the toy has either a flared base, a hook, or a T-bar. The anchor serves two purposes: it helps you keep your grip on the toy when inserting and removing it, and it prevents the plug from traveling too far up your anal cavity to where you can’t retrieve it. The anchor also strokes to the perineum when the toy is completely inside of you.

Sanitation

You should always clean your anal toy before and after each use. Placing a condom over it before insertion is highly recommended if you plan on sharing toys with a partner. You can clean nonporous toys with mild soap and water. If it does not vibrate, you can place metal and glass toys in boiling water to de-sanitize them.

If you choose a vibrating toy, use care when cleaning it. Unless otherwise stated, it is not waterproof. Using an antibacterial toy cleaner is best for these options (since you can’t submerge them). Even if your toy is submergible, having an antibacterial toy cleaner is more convenient to have on hand for the days you don’t feel like breaking out the pot.

Review of the Best Butt Plugs for Men

With many anal toys available today, selecting the right butt plug for you can be overwhelming. We’ve reviewed the top-rated butt plugs and prostate massagers for men to help inform your next purchase. Whether you want a simple yet effective toy or an option with all the bells and whistles, we have you covered.

Pros

  • Curved prostate plug with a T-bar anchor
  • Specifically designed for prostate pleasure
  • Reverse taper contracts muscles to hold on to it
  • Easy-to-clean silicone plug is compatible with water-based anal lubricant
  • 4” of insertable length and 1” diameter
  • Latex-free and phthalate-free
  • Indentation at the tip for targeted p-spot stimulation

Cons

  • Doesn’t vibrate
  • The handle is too flexible
  • Best for beginners only; intermediate users will be disappointed in the thickness
  • Sometimes slips out during orgasm

When beginning to introduce prostate play, it is best to start simple. The Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug has a simple design for men who want to experiment with prostate stimulation. The curved plug has a T-bar anchor that helps you hold on to it as you are sliding it in and removing it. When the toy is inside of you, the anchor rubs against your perineum for extra pleasure.

The Booty Buddy has a reverse taper – meaning that it is thicker at the top and narrower at the base – so that your contracting rectal muscles will securely grip it. This helps keep the toy firmly inserted. With 4” of insertable length and about 1” wide at the thickest point, this easy-to-clean silicone plug is latex-free and phthalate-free for completely body-safe play.

Bottom Line

The Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug is a great introduction to prostate stimulation. With a male-friendly design, the smooth plug slides inside of you, with a small indentation at the tip that slightly rubs the prostate for ultimate pleasure. Although it lacks the features of more elevated vibrating models, the ergonomic shape and smooth, body-safe material make it a perfect starter toy.

Pros

  • Hands-free, waterproof remote-control vibrating L-shaped prostate and perineum massager
  • 8 functions, 12 speeds of vibration
  • 4” insertable length, 1.25” diameter
  • Flexible silicone massager is latex-free and phthalate-free
  • Compatible with water-based anal lubricant
  • USB rechargeable with a travel lock to keep the toy from turning on during transit
  • Storage/charging case included

Cons

  • The wireless remote control is not waterproof
  • Long recharge time: 2 hours charge for 1 hour of use
  • Hard to keep inserted
  • Might be too big and heavy for beginners

For a decadent prostate massage, the Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager is an L-shaped plug with arms that stimulate your gland and your perineum at the same time. With 12 speeds and 8 functions of vibration, this toy arouses all of the sensitive nerve endings near your anus and rectum.

The prostate arm has a smooth curve for targeted prostate massage. The soft silicone material is completely body-safe – it is latex-free and phthalate-free, and it pairs with any water-based anal lubricant.

With a lock on the toy, you can bring it with you on your next vacation or business trip without it accidentally switching on during travel. The Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager comes with its own storage and recharging case, so you can discreetly keep it fully charged no matter where you are.

Bottom Line

The Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager is an upgrade for men who enjoy using plugs during their prostate play. This flexible L-shaped toy might be too big and heavy for anal newbies, but men with experience will love the silky silicone and the double vibrating stimulation of the prostate and perineum. With so many options for pleasure, this toy isn’t one to miss.

Pros

  • List Element
  • List Element
  • Compatible with water-based anal lube
  • Waterproof silicone plug with a T-bar anchor
  • A flexible toy that moves with you
  • 2 speeds, 5 functions of vibration
  • Curved, vibrating butt plug with an indentation for target p-spot stimulation

Cons

  • Removable bullet is hard to take out
  • Short battery life in the bullet
  • Weaker vibrations than most toys
  • No taper in plug (might slip out during orgasm)

For a gentle transition between finger stimulation and a prostate toy, the Lovehoney Booty Buddy Vibro 7 Function Vibrating Butt Plug adds smooth vibrations to a curved prostate massager. With a shape similar to a bent finger, this beginner vibrating toy is flexible enough to move with your body while hitting the gland with a slightly indented tip.

Compatible with water-based anal lubricant, the Booty Buddy Vibro has 2 speeds and 5 functions for extra stimulation. This silicone plug is easy to clean, and it is latex-free and phthalate-free for body-safe play. At 4” of insertable length and 1” diameter, the size may not impress an experienced anal player, but it will send thrills through any beginner to prostate play.

Bottom Line

The Lovehoney Booty Buddy Vibro 7 Function Vibrating Butt Plug is an excellent starter toy for men willing to take the plunge into the world of vibrating prostate massagers. It has a gentle vibration and a smooth curve for prostate, rectal, and anal stimulation.

While the T-bar anchor keeps the toy from sliding too far inside of you, the arms can get in the way during sex. For this reason, it is better for solo use. Although men with more experience with toys are disappointed by the Booty Buddy’s size and strength, it is the perfect first vibrating prostate massager.

Pros

  • Curved silicone butt plug with graduated beads along the shaft, a tapered tip, and a flexible flared base
  • Beads good for in and out movement
  • 10 function vibrations
  • The corded remote has separate buttons for on-off and switching speeds and functions
  • 1” diameter, 4” insertable length
  • Latex-free and phthalate-free

Cons

  • The wired remote isn’t long enough
  • Too small for intermediate users
  • Slips out easily
  • Base hard to grip with lubricated hands

If you have experimented with different anal toys, you know that the feeling of anal beads is much different than a prostate massager. The Dash 10 Function Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug combines the excitement of a butt plug, anal beads, and a prostate massager all in one toy.

With a slightly curved shaft and a tapered tip, the Dash is made of body-safe silicone that is latex-free and phthalate-free. It slides in easily with any water-based anal lubricant. The graduated beads connected by the shaft add the sensation of inserting vibrating anal beads.

With 10 functions of vibration, a wired remote control powers this toy, with separate controls for turning the toy on/off and changing the settings. While the size is more suited for beginners, the different textures and vibrations add more fun to your prostate play.

Bottom Line

While the Dash 10 Function Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug has an interesting design, it fails to deliver all that it promises. The wire is longer than most toys, but it isn’t long enough for full range of motion.

The graduated beads add an extra dimension to your anal play, but the only way this toy won’t fall out is if it is fully inserted: if you haven’t worked your way up to the largest bulb, it will slip out during orgasm. 

While the Dash has some shortcomings, it definitely has the power to provide some anal pleasure. As long as you don’t mind not using a hands-free toy, this one is worth checking out.

Pros

  • Borosilicate glass curved prostate massager
  • Body-safe, latex-free, and phthalate-free
  • Easy to clean with boiling water, mild soap, or toy cleaner
  • Temperature play
  • Curved shaft for fulfilling spread
  • Narrow neck above base for gripping
  • Compatible with all lubricants
  • 4” insertable length, 1” diameter

Cons

  • Slick when inserted
  • No storage bag
  • Too small for intermediate users

Although the Icicles No 46 Curved P-Spot is the only glass butt plug on our list, we saved the best toy for last. This borosilicate glass massager is the safest toy you can use. Completely body-safe, it is latex-free and phthalate-free, with a handy finger loop for retrieval. It is incredibly easy to clean by boiling it in water or washing it with soap or toy cleaner.

With a curved neck that stretches you delightfully, the Icicles No 46 Curved P-Spot Glass Butt Plug has a reverse taper to help your body hold the toy inside of you. Glass toys pair with any lubricant, so you aren’t limited to only one type of lube. For an extra slick feeling, use your favorite silicone lubricant.

At only 4” of insertable length and 1” diameter in the thickest part, this toy is the perfect introduction to glass toys. For some extra fun, run the plug under hot or cold water for some exciting temperature play.

Bottom Line

For a completely different experience, the Icicles No 46 Curved P-Spot Glass Butt Plug delivers. Although the material is harder than the rest of the silicone toys on this list, you won’t be able to tell once you heat it (or cool it down) and add your favorite lubricant. The gentle curves along the shaft create an extraordinary experience while the small size isn’t intimidating for beginners. It’s our favorite butt plug for men.

P-spot Pleasure! Perks of Butt Plugs for Men

The main benefit of using a butt plug is that it stimulates the prostate. This gland in the reproductive system adds fluid to sperm to create semen. Stimulating this gland also induces an intense orgasm, one that many men describe as an experience that you feel throughout your whole body.

The most intense part of the male orgasm is the beginning when the prostate produces and releases the fluid that combines with sperm. Stimulating this gland is part of a process known as “milking the prostate.”

Using butt plugs for prostate play is useful in every stage of the sexual experience.

  • They make your orgasms longer and more intense. When using a butt plug or a prostate massager, the toy makes direct contact to the gland. The insertion will contract the muscles in your anus and rectum, moving the plug inside of you. With the muscle movement, the toy rubs against your prostate in light, circular motions. This brings on an intense orgasm that is stronger and lasts longer, creating that “full-body” experience that men describe during prostate stimulation.

  • You can use them to enhance your solo missions. If you like to indulge in a little self-love, prostate massagers are a great tool. The prostate is known as the “male G-spot” – or the “P-spot” – because it feels similar to a woman’s G-spot orgasms. When using a toy during masturbation, it will intensify your whole experience. You’ll love it so much that you will wonder how you experienced masturbation without one.

  • Couples use butt plugs to add an extra dimension to their foreplay or sex. Many couples have been embracing using butt plugs and prostate massagers in their bedroom activities. Inserting a toy during oral stimulation can add extra pleasure before the main event. Some couples will keep it inserted during sex. The plug brings you to orgasm more quickly for a more fulfilling experience.  

  • Using a prostate massager has health benefits. Engaging in the occasional prostate play has health benefits. Physicians have suggested milking the prostate for thousands of years to improve men's’ sexual health. Bringing on a prostate orgasm helps reduce the chances of cancer and other health conditions.

Conclusion

If you have been considering a foray into prostate pleasure, a butt plug is the best way to get started. Many of these toys are made with body-safe materials that are easy to clean, and they are relatively simple to use. Meant to be left inside of you during play, your body will naturally grip the toy for a hands-free experience. Your muscles contract, slowly rubbing the toy against your prostate for mind-blowing pleasure.