Best Vibrating Butt Plugs of 2020 (Max Pleasure Review)

Have you had your heart set on the idea of a vibrating butt plug but haven’t been sure where to start? Well, I’m here to help!

With you find the right toy, vibrating butt plugs can be a whole lot of fun and they can be used in so many different types of play.

Picking the right one can be tricky though, especially if you don’t know where to start. That’s why we have made it easy and picked the best of the year.

Comparison Chart of the Best Vibrating Butt Plugs

Product 

Our Rating

Price

Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet Vibrating Butt Plug

Best Overall

Lovehoney Butt Tingler Vibrating Butt Plug Small

Best for the Money

Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug

Best Inflatable Vibrating Butt Plug

BASICS Vibrating

Butt Plug

Best Beginner Vibrating Butt Plug

Booty Blaster Thrusting & Vibrating Butt Plug

Best Thrusting Vibrating Butt Plug

Pros and Cons of Vibrating Butt Plugs

The anus is full of thousands of nerve endings and a vibrating butt plug is designed to stimulate as many of those as it can! Just like a non-vibrating butt plug, a vibrating one will create a feeling of pressure and fullness inside the body which can make other sensations feel more intense.

For females, this fullness can also be felt through the thin wall of the vagina and make a vaginal orgasm possible and more intense too. For men, some shapes will hit the prostate too and make your orgasm much more intense.

Adding some vibration into the mix amps everything up a notch by targeting more nerve endings, especially the ones around the opening of the anus. The only downside to a vibrating plug is that it can be more difficult to clean, as some will not be waterproof. Make sure you follow the instructions of your toy, and you should be fine.

How to Choose a Vibrating Butt Plug

Choosing a vibrating butt plug can actually be pretty easy so long as you know what to look for. When it comes to this type of toy, these are the most important things to consider.

Material

What is the toy made of? This will determine how the toy feels inside you if there is any flexibility, which type of lubricant you can use, and how easily the toy will be inserted. If you are unsure I recommend silicone as it is smooth but still has some squish in most cases, it is also easy to insert, body safe and non-porous. Just don’t use it with silicone lube.

Size

The size will literally determine if you can actually use the toy or not, so be honest with yourself. If you are a beginner, start small. If you go too big, you may hurt yourself or not be able to even insert the toy. Look at the measurements and be realistic with your own body and level of experience.

Controlling the Vibration

The other thing to think about is how the vibration is controlled. Some toys will use a button on the push and others will actually have a remote control. If you want to use it with a partner, then a remote can be a lot of fun! Button controls can be difficult to change once inserted especially if there is a lot of lube involved.

Review of the Best Vibrating Butt Plugs

Now that you know what to look out for when you buy, here are our favorites!

Best Overall:
Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet

Pros

  • Nice, strong vibrations and lots of different modes to choose from.
  • The wire between the toy and the controller is long enough that it won’t get in the way and it can be given to someone else easily.
  • The base is actually a suction cup so you can use it hands-free.

Cons

  • The controller is made from plastic and it can get slippery when wet so be careful if you get lubes on your hands.
  • The base could do with a wider flare to it to make sure it doesn’t go inside the body.

Let’s start off with a cute and petite beginners butt plug that packs a punch. This plug is made from smooth silicone and has a tapered tip for easy insertion.

It has a 4-inch insertable length and a 4-inch circumference so it is a great size for newbies to anal play or more advanced users looking for something small and cute to use. There are 7 different vibration patterns and 3 different speeds so there won’t be any getting bored with this toy. 

The vibrations are controlled using a wired remote control so it is a great toy to use alone or to give a partner control of. The plug is battery operated and it isn’t waterproof so don’t use it in the shower and be careful when you are cleaning it.

Bottom Line

This butt plug is super cheap and fun, but it is not the best quality. However, it’s a great gateway toy into more anal vibration play.

Best for the Money:
Lovehoney Butt Tingler

Pros

  • Great small size and a tapered tip so that insertion is easy.
  • This is a fully waterproof option which can be used in the bath or shower.
  • The flared base is large enough that it won’t get sucked up into your body while you play.

Cons

  • The button at the base may be difficult to change modes once inserted.
  • The bullet is not removable even though it looks like it.
  • The vibrations aren’t the strongest but it is designed for beginners so that is to be expected.

This is another small vibrating butt plug that is perfect for beginners. This is a simple black silicone plug with 2 vibration speeds and 3 different vibration patterns.

It uses a single click button at the base of the plug to scroll through the different modes of vibration and has no remote. It is battery operated and is actually fully submersible in water so long as you have the battery cap on as tight as it goes. 

This is a classic butt plug shape with a nice wide flared base. It is also a t-shape base which some people find sits more comfortably between their butt cheeks. It has an insertable length of 3.5 inches and a girth of 3.5 inches at its widest point.

Bottom Line

This is a great beginner vibrating plug, especially for those that like some water play. It may not be the strongest, but it is a nice entry toy.

Best Inflatable Vibrating Butt Plug:
Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug

Pros

  • An inflatable toy allows you to train your body without too much strain.
  • As this size is customizable it allows you lots of different ways to play and a whole lot of different sensations.
  • It is a great anal toy for intermediate to advanced users.

Cons

  • The hand pump is a bit fiddly and it can sometimes separate from the tube.
  • As this toy is made from rubber, it requires a lot of lubricant to stay slippery and comfortable during use.

Now, onto something a bit different… something inflatable! Inflatable butt plugs are ideal for those that want to see how far they can stretch without putting too much strain on the sphincter muscles. They can also be a great tool for those that want to train their bodies to move up to larger toys.

The idea is that you insert the toy, then use the hand pump to inflate it once it is inserted so that you can customize the girth. This plug starts at 4.5 inches in insertable length and 5 inches in girth. Once inflated, it can go up to 9 inches in girth.

There is a quick release button for when you are done to deflate the toy too. And this one even has some vibration too! There is a handheld control with a dial to go through the different vibration speeds.

Bottom Line

If you are looking for a bigger vibrating but plug that will give you a great stretch, then this plug may just be perfect. Remember the lube though!

Best Beginner Vibrating Butt Plug:
BASICS Vibrating Butt Plug

Pros

  • The size and shape make it great for beginners or for use as a warm-up toy.
  • The bullet which controls the vibrations is actually removable so you can use it as a stand-alone bullet vibe too.

Cons

  • There may be hard edges which can be sharp or uncomfortable. It's not suitable for long-term wear.
  • It is not waterproof.

This vibrating butt plug by Basics is another good option for beginners as it has an extremely thin tip which makes insertion nice and easy. In fact, the tip is only 0.25 inches which are very small for a butt plug.

You can also use this thin tip in an in and out motion to warm up the booty before you go all in. The girth slowly graduates to a larger size as it gets closer to the base and has a maximum circumference of 3.75 inches and an insertable length of 3.5 inches.

This is another battery operated plug and it has just one single speed but it is pretty good and can be felt throughout the whole plug. It is made from firm PVC so it will be fairly firm inside the body without flexibility.

Bottom Line

If you are looking for an entry level vibrating plug that will give you a good time, but not necessarily lasts a long time, then this might be the perfect starter plug for you.

Best Thrusting Vibrating Butt Plug:
Booty Blaster Thrusting Vibrating Butt Plug

Pros

  • This toy has both vibration and thrusting so there are all sorts of different ways to enjoy the stimulation.
  • The shape is almost like a real penis and combined with the thrusting function, it mimics real anal sex.
  • The flared base doubles as a suction cup so you can use it hands-free.

Cons

  • Thrusting is not very powerful and requires a lot of lube to work. It also tends to fizzle if your body is too tight for it.
  • It needs to be suctioned completely to a surface or the end will move in and out instead of the tip into the body.

Non-beginners, we haven’t forgotten about you! The Booty Blaster is slightly bigger than some of the others and has 10 different vibration modes designed for some serious booty pleasure. Oh, and it also thrusts!

This plug has a penis like shape that is bulbous at the head, then thins through the body before getting girthier again towards the base. Its made of firm plastic and 5.5 inches of insertable length and 4.5 inches’ circumference at its widest point. There are 7 vibration patterns to explore and 3 different thrusting speeds so you can use it just the way you like it.

Bottom Line

As long as you use the suction cup then this is a great toy to mimic anal sex. I don’t recommend it for beginners though.

​Conclusion

And there you have it, our picks for the best vibrating butt plugs. No matter your experience level, shape or color preference, there is a plug for you. Sometimes you just need a little help to find it!