Best Prostate Butt Plugs – 2020 Review

Time to hit the “P-spot”! The male prostate is a walnut-sized gland about 3-4 inches inside the rectum and towards the stomach. The prostate not only produces sperm-nourishing goodness to semen, but also contains some smooth muscles involved in ejaculation. Men report that massaging the prostate gives them stronger, more intense orgasms.

Here are some great products to help stimulate this wonderful spot.

Comparison Chart of the Best Prostate Butt Plugs

Product 

Our Rating

Price

Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug

Fifty Shades of Grey Driven by Desire Silicone

Butt Plug

Rocks Off O-Boy Beginner's Vibrating Prostate Massager

Dash Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug

Tracey Cox Supersex Vibrating Butt Plug

Best Vibrating

Prostate Butt Plug

Types of Prostate Butt Plugs

Non-Vibrating Prostate Plug

The main goal of a prostate butt plug is to provide constant stimulation to the area. This is achieved first and foremost by a plug curved to hit that spot on the front of the rectum where the prostate gland is most easily accessible. If you are a newbie to P-spot toy play, a smaller, non-vibrating plug is your first stop on the way to anal delight.

Vibrating Prostate Plug

If you want to amp it up a notch, you can get a prostate butt plug with a buzzy kick. To accommodate a vibrating motor, these plugs may be a bit girthier for than their non-vibrating counterparts. This makes them more suitable for experienced users. Look for designs with varying speeds so you can find a setting that is not too strong, not too weak, but just right for you.

Aspects of our Favorite Prostate Butt Plugs

Shape 

Gotta hit the spot, right? A good prostate butt plug is going to have a shape that is designed to focus stimulation on the front of the rectum. A good plug is going to have a curve or tilt as opposed to a straight shape. Even better ones will have additional curves to hit other erogenous zones like the anal entrance or perineum plus a comfortable ergonomic base.

Material

We want all of our sex toys to be clean and hypoallergenic, but this goes double for anal toys. Silicone is king of sex toys materials. Stable, non-porous and soft to the touch, silicone toys are almost always going to be our top pick.

Powerful, versatile and waterproof vibration

If it’s going to buzz, it better do it with gusto. The best vibrating butt plugs are going to have several settings, plenty of power and unobtrusive controls. An added bonus is waterproof battery packs that let you take your prostate massager into the shower or tub.

Review of the Best Prostate Butt Plugs

Ready to ride the P-spot wave? Here’s our picks for the best prostate butt plugs.

1. Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug

Lovehoney’s Booty Buddy is a firm but flexible, silicone butt plug with a shaft that is 4 inches long, 2.75 inches around and curved to hit the P-spot. The comfy flared T-bar base is contoured to natural body shape, keeps the plug in place and stimulates the perineum. Waterproof and easy to insert, this little wonder works for newbies, pros and for extended wear.

play

Pros

  • Curved shape
  • Flared base
  • Silicone
  • Suitable for newbies and pros

Cons

  • Non-vibrating
  • May be underwhelming to new users

Bottom Line

If you are trying out prostate stimulation for the first time, Lovehoney’s Booty Buddy is a great economical starter. Smartly designed and easy to use, it will do the job without overwhelming you with vibration or bulk.

2. Fifty Shades of Grey Driven by Desire Silicone Butt Plug

Fifty Shades of Grey Driven by Desire plug is a velvet-soft silicone toy with a bent tip to target the prostate. This plug is 3 inches around with a 3.5 inch insertable shaft making it especially good for beginners. It has a flared T-bar base like Booty Buddy but is slightly more rounded and curved  for added comfort.

play

Pros

  • Curved shape
  • Flared, rounded base
  • Silicone
  • Perfect for beginners

Cons

  • Non-vibrating
  • Too small for experienced users

Bottom Line

Fifty Shades of Grey Driven by Desire butt plug is almost identical to Lovehoney’s Booty Buddy with just a few tweaks to the base shape that may make it more comfortable to wear. If you want to spend a few more dollars and get a plug that is perfect for a newbie with slightly more ergonomic in shape, Driven by Desire is a good choice. Experienced users complained of slippage due to its small size though, so keep that in mind if this isn’t your first butt plug rodeo.

3. Rocks Off 7 Function O-Boy Beginner's Vibrating Prostate Massager

Now for some buzz. Rocks Off O-Boy Vibrating Prostate Massager is designed with the beginner in mind. It is easily insertable with a curved silicone 5 inch long shaft that is also 3.5 inches around. This plug has a flared base for perineal stimulation. The removable, 7 function bullet vibrator runs on one included N battery and is waterproof. Controls are push button. 

play

Pros

  • Curved shape
  • Flared base
  • Silicone and 100% waterproof
  • Good for beginners
  • Removable bullet with 7 speeds and patterns

Cons

  • Batteries will need replacing
  • Too small for experienced users
  • Some users found it too flexible to insert easily

Bottom Line

If you are looking for a beginner prostate stimulating butt plug that vibrates, Rocks Off gets rave reviews. It is small and comfortable with several speeds and patterns to choose from. We like the wireless design though some users found the base a little difficult to hold. Experienced users also tended to find this plug too small and prone to slipping out.

4. Dash 10 Function Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug

Dash 10 finally gives us a variation on the prostate massager design! This 10 function, silicone butt plug that has a pointed tip and a 4 inch long and 3.5 inch around, beaded shaft for extra pleasure. The flared base is ultra-flexible for extra stimulation of the perineum. The wired 2-button controller is connected via 28 inch cable and runs on 1 AA battery. This toy is waterproof.

play

Pros

  • Silicone
  • 10 speeds and patterns
  • Waterproof
  • Ultra-flexible flared base
  • Unique pointed tip and beaded shaft

Cons

  • Battery will need replacing
  • Wire gets in the way / could be longer
  • Some users found it too small / slipped out

Bottom Line

Dash 10 is a cleverly designed prostate stimulator with a series of bumps similar to anal beads. It’s silicone, extra flexible and has a great variety of vibration settings.  For a new to intermediate user, this one ticks all the boxes but may be too small for advanced users.

5. Best Vibrating Prostate Butt Plug: Tracey Cox Supersex Vibrating Butt Plug

Our top pick for the best vibrating prostate butt plugs is the Tracey Cox Supersex plug. Made out of rigid ABS and 3 inches long with girthy 3.75 inch circumference, the plug has a curved shape for prostate stimulation and  a flared base. The handy 2-button, wired controller offers 4 speeds, runs on 3 AA batteries and is waterproof.

play

Pros

  • Curved and girthy shaft
  • Flared base
  • 4 vibration speeds
  • Waterproof

Cons

  • Batteries will need replacing
  • Wire gets in the way
  • ABS as opposed to silicone

Bottom Line

In spite of being ABS rather than silicone, Tracey Cox’s Supersex Vibrating Butt Plug is a bestseller that gets rave reviews from users. With its the girthy design, powerful vibrations and waterproof design, it is a great choice for more advanced users. Plus, we like that you can use a long lasting silicone lube with this toy.

How to Use a Prostate Butt Plug

Use lots of lube. Silicone is best, but with a silicone toy opt for a long lasting water-based lubricant.

Warm up. Be sure to get ample foreplay and try inserting a lubricated finger first to locate the exact position of the prostate. It will feel like a firm but plush lump about 3-4” inside the rectum and towards the belly button. Some men experience immediate arousal or the sensation of needing to urinate when it is touched.

Check the position of the curve of your plug. The prostate is on the anterior wall of the rectum, so the curve should be on your belly side not towards the sides or tailbone.

Relax your sphincter and insert your well-lubricated plug slowly. Comfortable insertion can take up to a minute per inch the first time. Stop if you meet too much resistance or it is uncomfortable.

Gently adjust the position of the plug until it hits the right spot. Make sure the base remains on the outside. If using a vibrating plug, start with the lowest setting and work up to higher speeds overtime. 

Enjoy! With practice, plugs can be worn up to 30 minutes or more.

Conclusion

Prostate stimulation can put a real bang in the male orgasm. Butt plugs with just the right amount of kink can hit that target and help give your good times an amazing climax.