Best Lube for Butt Plugs – 2020 Review

Ask anyone who has experimented with anal play, and they will tell you there is nothing, repeat nothing, more important to a good experience than the type of lubricant you use. But with all the lubes available for purchase, how do you know which one is best? Read on to learn about the best lubes for butt plug use.

Comparison of the Best Lube for Butt Plugs

Product 

Our Rating

Price

Doc Johnson Golden Girl Anal Jelly

Sliquid Sassy Water-Based Anal Lubricant

Sliquid Organics Natural Gel Lubricant

Doc Johnson Natural Anal Lubricant Tub

Fifty Shades of Grey At Ease Anal Lubricant

Types of Anal Lube Perfect for Butt Plugs

With the wide variety of lubricants out there on the market today, you may be feeling a bit overwhelmed when it comes to choosing the perfect one to use with your butt plug. Luckily for you, when it comes to butt plugs, it’s more about which lubes to avoid.

Many butt plugs are made of silicone or a silicone derivative, and that means using a silicone-based lube is an absolute no-no. We understand that silicone lubes are some of the silkiest, smoothest lubricants out there, and maybe other lubes may not feel quite as nice, but silicone lubricants will eat away at silicone and leave your butt plug warped and potentially unsafe.

The other big lube to avoid when engaging in any sort of anal play is numbing lube. Because the anal area is so sensitive, it can be tempting to desensitize it a bit, but pain is there for a reason, and you do not want to get into a situation where you don’t realize your toy is hurting you because you have numbed yourself too much.

How to Choose Butt Plug Lube

Okay, so now you know about which kind of lubricants to stay away from. But what about the lubes that can actually be beneficial for your butt plug experience? The first aspect you want to look out for when choosing a butt plug lubricant is the material used for its base.

We have already mentioned that silicone lube is no good, and typically you want to stay away from oil-based lubes as well (and you definitely want to stay away from oil-based lubes when playing with toys that are made of latex or rubber – metal, glass, and plastic toys will probably be okay, but better safe than sorry).

Water-based lube is really the way to go when playing with anal toys.

You are also going to want to make sure the lube is particularly thick and long-lasting – the last thing you’re going to want is to have to constantly remove your plug to reapply lube (it can really kill the moment). The thicker and more viscous the lube, the better it will work for use with your plug.

Review of the Best Butt Plug Lubricants

So now that you have a better sense of what types of lubes work best with butt plugs, let’s look at some actual lubricant products!

1. Doc Johnson Golden Girl Anal Jelly

The Doc Johnson Golden Girl Anal Jelly is a great, basic anal lubricant that will help your butt plug enter with ease. It is oil-based, so be mindful that you do not use it on particular types of toys as outlined above. But for other kinds of toys, you have got it made!

This lubricant is thick without being runny, so you do not ever have to worry about cleaning up any sort of mess. Users report that two finger-fulls of this lube is more than enough for anything they wanted to try, so one tub should last you a good deal of time. That situation also goes for when applying the lube itself – it does not disappear or be absorbed quickly, so you will not need to constantly re-apply throughout your activities.

Pros

  • Tub is easily opened even with slippery hands
  • Extremely thick and a little goes a long way
  • Mess-free, not runny
  • Lasts a long time and does not require frequent re-application
  • Significantly enhances the anal experience

Cons

  • Does have slight desensitizing properties, but not enough to be a concern

Bottom Line

The Doc Johnson Golden Girl Anal Jelly is a great, reliable lube for anal play and especially for playing with butt plugs. Be mindful of its slight desensitization properties, though.

2. Sliquid Sassy Water-Based Anal Lubricant

The Sliquid Sassy Water-Based Anal Lubricant is the premier choice in water-based, natural lubes. If you are looking for something that can be used on all of your different types of butt plugs, all of the time, Sliquid is a great option for you.

If, additionally, it is important to you not to put any extra unnecessary chemicals in your body, or to not use products that have been tested on animals, Sliquid checks all of those boxes too! Users also report that it is an effective lube beyond just anal activities.

Pros

  • Water-based, so can be used with all imaginable toys
  • Comes in a large bottle, so more bang for your buck
  • Odorless and tasteless
  • Thick, not runny in the slightest
  • Pea sized amount does the trick

Cons

  • Feminine packaging may be off-putting to some users

Bottom Line

The Sliquid Sassy Water-Based Anal Lubricant is an awesome lubricant for anyone looking for a good anal lube that also can be used on any toy and is all natural and cruelty free. If you are the type of person to not enjoy feminine packaging, though, this lube is not for you.

3. Sliquid Organics Natural Gel Lubricant

The Sliquid Organics Natural Gel Lubricant is ideal for those users who may be a little bit more wary about what they put inside their bodies. It is all natural, with no chemical ingredients. If you have ever had tears or other sensitivity issues with anal play, the Sliquid Organics lube may be the best option for you.

Because it is water-based, it can be used on any and all types of plugs and also will never make any sort of sticky mess. It is great for both anal and vaginal use, particularly for those users who may also have more sensitive vaginas.

Pros

  • Not sticky
  • Washes out of things easily
  • Good for sensitive skin
  • Odorless and tasteless
  • Good for both anal and vaginal use
  • mail-forward
    All natural

Cons

  • Does not last as long as other water-based lubricants on the market

Bottom Line

The Sliquid Organics Natural Gel Lubricant is an awesome choice for people trying to avoid use of any chemicals or those who may have more sensitive situations back there. However, it does not last a super long time and you may need to use more of it as a result.

4. Doc Johnson Natural Anal Lubricant Tub

The Doc Johnson Natural Anal Lubricant Tub is an awesome, oil-based lubricant for anal play. Keep in mind again that, because it is oil-based, it is not for use on all different types of butt plugs. But, on the plus side, the oily, Vaseline-like consistency of this lube creates a whole new level of wetness and penetration ability.

With most lubes, there is no such thing as too much, but with the Doc Johnson Natural Tub, you will need only the bare minimum. Also, because it is oil-based and not water-based, you can take it with you for some play time in the bath or shower!

Pros

  • Not messy, will not cause any stains
  • A little goes a long way and re-application is usually unnecessary
  • Oil-based, so feels especially slippery
  • Water-resistant, able to be used in the bath and shower

Cons

  • Unpleasant taste
  • Tub pump does not work

Bottom Line

The Doc Johnson Natural Anal Lubricant Tub is a great choice for those looking for a slippery, water-resistant lubricant. Just try not to taste it if you can avoid it.

5. Fifty Shades of Grey At Ease Anal Lubricant

The Fifty Shades of Grey At Ease Anal Lubricant is one of the best anal lubricants out there in terms of thickness. In fact, it is so thick it can sometimes be difficult to even get it out of the bottle!

With that complication aside, the lube thins out once it is applied and forms a smooth protective layer that will enhance pleasure from any butt plug (and it is water-based, so it can be used on any toy imaginable!).

If you are into the Fifty Shades of Grey line, this lubricant also comes with their distinctive branding and a quote from the book, if that may add to your pleasure.  

Pros

  • Lasts a long time
  • Easy to transport because of the smaller size
  • One of the thickest anal lubes available
  • No stickiness

Cons

  • Smaller bottle than most other brands, so less bang for your buck
  • Bottle also has a small opening which can be difficult to navigate

Bottom Line

The Fifty Shades of Grey At Ease Anal Lubricant is an awesome, thick anal lube. It does come in a smaller bottle and can be difficult to get out in the heat of the moment.

Conclusion

Butt plugs are a glorious source of pleasure, but they are pretty useless without a good lubricant option. Make sure you are aware of the different lube needs you may have based on your different toys, and check out some of the options listed above to take your anal play experience to the next level!