Best Butt Plugs for Beginners – 2020 Review

So, you’ve decided that you want to try anal penetration. Now what? You can’t just stick anything up there. Your back door is a delicate part of the body that needs gentle care.

Luckily for you, there are a wide range of toys that will introduce you to the world of anal stimulation.  

Comparison of the Best Beginner Butt Plugs

Product 

Our Rating

Price

BASICS Slimline Butt Plug

Best Overall

Cupid's Itty Bitty Beginner's Plug

Runner-up

Lovehoney Get Started Beginner's Anal Kit

(4 Piece)

Best for the Money

Lovehoney Classic Silicone Beginner's Butt Plug

BASICS Beaded Anal Prober with Finger Loop

How to Choose Your First Butt Plug

Since using a toy that is too big for you can cause pain or damage, you should look at the size of different plugs to see what makes you feel comfortable. If the size of a toy visually intimidates you, then it will make you nervous before you use it. Your muscles naturally tense when you are scared or anxious, making the experience more likely to be a bad one. Anal pleasure is best taken slowly, with the size of your toy increasing with your comfort level.

When choosing your first plug, there are a few essential characteristics that should attract you.  

  • Small, slender shape. Butt plugs come in many different shapes. Most are cone-shaped, while others have a bulb or a spade shape to them. For your first plug, choose a slimline or petite model. These are both small and slender, making your first use much more enjoyable.

  • Stick to body-safe materials that are latex-free and phthalate-free. Sex toy manufacturers are required by law to inform you whether or not a product contains latex or phthalates. When looking at the specifications for your options, always choose the toys that are labeled latex-free and phthalate-free. These toys are body-safe, meaning that they have the best materials for sexual play.

  • Silicone, metal, or glass? Silicone is softer than glass or metal toys, but that shouldn’t be your only deciding factor. Glass and metal toys have their own benefits. They hold temperature well, so they will slowly warm up from your body heat as you are using them. You can also run these materials under cold water or place them in the freezer to test out more cooling sensations.

  • A flared base keeps the plug in place. The worst fear that any anal newbie has when it comes to anal toys is: what if it gets stuck up there? While this is a possibility with the naturally-contracting muscles in the anus and the rectum, the flared base of a butt plug keeps this from happening. This is why they are favorites among anal players of all experience levels. The base sits directly against your anus, holding the plug where is it supposed to be.

Review of the Best Beginner Butt Plugs

Now that you know what you should look for in your first anal toy, we’ve reviewed the best butt plugs for beginners. They have different styles and shapes, so you will be able to find one that suits your preference.

1. BASICS Slimline Butt Plug

Pros

  • Slim butt plug with a flared, suction-cup base that sticks to any smooth surface
  • The PVC material is latex-free and phthalate-free for body-safe play
  • Compatible with silicone or water-based lubricant
  • Tapered for easy insertion
  • 4.5” insertable length and 1” diameter
  • mail-forward
    Flexible shape for a gentle stretch

Cons

  • Feels sticky
  • Neck and plug are very similar in size

The best beginner toys have a slender profile that is less intimidating than the more defined “cone” shape of other anal plugs. The BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is a thin, tapered plug that is best for those new to anal penetration.

With a similar width to the human finger, the BASICS works best for men and women who want to experiment with anal toys. The PVC material is latex-free and phthalate-free, so it is perfect for body-safe play.

The BASICS is 1” wide at the thickest point, with 4.5” of insertable length. With a gentle taper, the plug slides in easily with silicone or water-based anal lubricant. The flexible design gently stretches your anal cavity without overwhelming you, which is helpful for those using a plug for the first time.

Bottom Line

For the best starter toy, the BASICS Slimline Butt Plug doesn’t disappoint. Designed for the first foray into anal penetration, this toy is body-safe and pairs well with most lubricants. The neck and plug are almost the same width, so it might slip out once your body gets used to the shape.  The slimmer size probably won’t satisfy those used to other toys, but it is the perfect style for beginners.

2. Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug

Pros

  • mail-forward
    Easy to clean
  • 2” insertable length, 1” diameter
  • mail-forward
    Compatible with water-based lubricant
  • Latex-free and phthalate-free silicone butt plug
  • Small, tapered teardrop shape for beginners
  • Has a flared base and a finger hook for more control over insertion and removal
  • When inserted, the thicker part of the plug rests along the end of the rectum where there are more nerves for stimulation

Cons

  • Finger loop is small
  • Silicone can get dirty during storage

Just because you are putting a toy up your bum doesn’t mean it can’t be pretty. The Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug is a body-safe, latex-free and phthalate-free silicone butt plug designed as a first-time toy.

The small, tapered teardrop shape is ergonomically curved to fit a woman’s body. The thicker end of the plug, when inserted, applies pressure to the nerves at the end of the rectum for more exciting play. Compatible with water-based anal lubricant, this silicone toy is easy to clean with soap and water.

With only 2” of insertable length and 1” thickness at the widest point, the Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug is the perfect size for anyone who wants a super small toy to “try” anal penetration. Smaller than most fingers, the plug slides in smoothly for comfortable wear. Great for solo use or with a partner, this toy arouses you in all the right places.

Bottom Line

Most beginners to butt plugs will be more comfortable using their new purchase if it is visually appealing. The Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug gives you a slight stretch for your first anal toy, with the added appeal of being cute as a button. The finger loop at the end makes it look like a teardrop-shaped ring pop. Although the hook is a little small for users with thicker fingers, it still helps you control your experience. This toy is worth checking out.

3. Lovehoney Get Started Beginner’s Anal Kit (4 Piece)

Pros

  • Selection of four different anal toys for beginner to intermediate users
  • Includes vibrating and non-vibrating toys
  • Wireless vibrating butt plug and vibrating beaded anal probe have variable speeds for finding the right amount of stimulation
  • Body-safe PVC material
  • Great for both men and women
  • mail-forward
    All toys are flexible, except for the firmer vibrating plug
  • mail-forward
    Compatible with water-based anal lubricant

Cons

  • Toys with curves and bulbs need more attention when cleaning
  • No storage bag to keep everything together
  • Batteries in vibrating toys run out quickly

Selecting your first toy can be so overwhelming: what if you don’t like the one you choose? With the Lovehoney Get Started Beginner’s Anal Kit, you can buy with confidence. With four different anal toys designed for beginners, you can try each one to see which shape you like better.

The set includes a slimline butt plug, a two-sided anal wand with curves and beads, a vibrating beaded anal probe, and a wireless vibrating butt plug with a more defined taper. All of the toys are made with a body-safe PVC material, with the perfect sizes for beginner to intermediate users.

If you have been wondering how vibrating and non-vibrating toys feel differently, this is your ideal purchase. You can experiment with both models to see which one gives you the most pleasure. Compatible with water-based anal lubricant, this set allows for a wider range of anal play than purchasing one toy alone.

All of the items are flexible, except for the wireless vibrating butt plug which has a firmer material. If you are a brave beginner who will try anything once, the Lovehoney Get Started Beginner’s Anal Kit lets you do just that.

Bottom Line

The Lovehoney Get Started Beginner’s Anal Kit is perfect for the more experienced beginner. Including each type of anal toy, this collection comes with a variety of options for anal pleasure. The curves and bulbs of some of the toys require extra attention when cleaning, so it’s best to use an antibacterial toy cleaner.

One minor complaint is that the batteries run low on the vibrating toys, but keeping extra batteries on hand will eliminate this issue. The Get Started Kit is a great introduction to the world of anal toys. Instead of trying to decide what you like, why not try it all?

4. Lovehoney Classic Silicone Beginner’s Butt Plug

Pros

  • Petite silicone anal plug for anal newbies
  • Tapered tip for easy insertion, with a firm yet flexible build
  • Compatible with water-based anal lubricant
  • 4” insertable length, 1” diameter
  • Hypoallergenic material is latex-free and phthalate-free
  • mail-forward
    Latex-free and phthalate-free
  • mail-forward
    Great for shower or tub play, solo or partner play, prostate stimulation, or use during sex

Cons

  • The slight size difference between the plug and the neck doesn’t give the true feeling of a larger plug
  • The flared base is wide and large

Another amazing starter item is the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Beginner’s Butt Plug. This petite silicone anal plug has a smooth finish and a tapered tip for smooth insertion. When you place the toy inside of you, it is firm yet flexible for a more comfortable experience.

Compatible with water-based anal lubricant, the toy measures 4” of insertable length and 1” diameter. The hypoallergenic silicone material is body-safe, latex-free, and phthalate-free. The Classic Silicone Beginner’s Plug is easy to clean with mild soap and water.

If you have been wondering why plugs are so popular, the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Beginner’s Butt Plug is a great place to start. It is a small, thin accessory perfect for a variety of sexual activities.

Bottom Line

While the extremely slim Lovehoney Classic Silicone Beginner’s Butt Plug doesn’t have the same cone shape as other small plugs, it is a good step up from a finger. Men and women love the decadent feel of the smooth silicone when paired with a good water-based lubricant. This toy is only for the anal toy newbie to help you get used to the feeling of a toy inside of you.

The flared base is too wide and large for any other activities, so it is best for solo sessions. With a quality construction for a budget-friendly price, the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Beginner’s Butt Plug is an excellent introduction to using butt plugs for anal penetration.

5. BASICS Beaded Anal Prober with Finger Loop

Pros

  • Graduated beaded probe with a smooth curve between the sections for beginners to anal probes
  • Can slide more of the toy inside of you according to your comfort level
  • Hook loop at the neck for more control over the movement
  • Made of latex-free and phthalate-free skin-safe rubber
  • 5.5” insertable length, 1.4” diameter at widest point
  • mail-forward
    Great for experimenting with anal play or DP
  • mail-forward
    Pairs with water-based lubricant for a smooth glide

Cons

  • No flared base after the neck
  • Loop too small for larger fingers
  • A rigid toy with very little flex for starters
  • Can slip out if you don’t have it inserted all the way during orgasm

Not all butt plugs have the cone shape that makes this type of toy so recognizable. The BASICS Beaded Anal Prober with Finger Loop 5.25 Inch is for men and women who desire something other than the traditional plug. The toy measures 5.5” of insertable length and 1.4” wide at the thickest point, a size that is best for beginners who want more variation in their anal plug.

With graduated beads along the length of the toy, you can control your experience, sliding more of it inside of you according to your comfort level. The smooth curve that connects the beads makes it ideal for beginners who enjoy movement in their anal play.

With a hook loop at the neck for easy handling, the BASICS Beaded Anal Prober is made of skin-safe rubber, and it is latex-free and phthalate-free for a body-safe experience. This toy pairs with any water-based anal lubricant for a smooth and satisfying glide.

While it is great for solo play, it is even better for couples. You can experiment with anal penetration or DP fantasies by inserting the toy during foreplay or sex. With so many options for pleasure, the BASICS Beaded Anal Prober with Finger Loop is a must-have item for any anal exploration.

Bottom Line

Anal probes are just as popular as butt plugs in the anal toy category. If the idea of a longer probe turns you on more than a plug, then the BASICS Beaded Anal Prober is a great way to test out this model without breaking the bank. Although this toy has a similar design to more advanced models, the beads are not as defined as they are in other anal probes.

The BASICS Beaded Anal Prober is an excellent start for someone who prefers this shape, but it isn’t an indicator of what other models would feel like when inserted. It is better as a starter toy to other larger anal toys, such as plugs and wands.  

Pros and Cons of Butt Plugs

Butt plugs are the first go-to toy for men and women who want to experiment with anal stimulation and penetration. Their popularity lies in their simplicity. Butt plugs are a cone-shaped toy with a taper that leads to a slender neck and a flared base. When you slide it inside of you, the sphincter – the ring-shaped muscle around the anus that separates your rectum from the outside world – closes around the neck, holding the toy in place. For this reason, plugs are very user-friendly: they are designed to be placed inside of you and left there during sexual activity.

This type of toy is only one of several designs for anal penetration. There are pros and cons associated with each kind of toy, and butt plugs have their own benefits and drawbacks.

Pros

  • Stretches the anal cavity. When you insert the toy, the plug spreads the anus open, allowing the top end of the toy to sit in your rectum. While this sounds painful, it shouldn’t be if you start with a small toy and work your way up to larger ones when you are comfortable with an upgrade.  

  • Stimulates sensitive nerves in the rectum using pressure. The sphincter is only one part of the anal cavity. The area at the beginning of the rectum is filled with extra sensitive nerves just waiting to be stimulated. Much like clitoral and vaginal orgasms, the right stimulation of these nerves can either lead to or intensify orgasms.

  • Vibrating options add further arousal of the nerves. Many butt plugs come in vibrating styles. They can be a steady vibration that you adjust manually, or they can have pre-set functions and speeds. The waves of vibration will add extra stimulation to the rectum, enhancing your pleasure.

  • Nonporous materials such as silicone, glass, and metal are very easy to keep clean with mild soap and water or toy cleaner. The best materials in your first sex toy are silicone, glass, and metal. These are nonporous, making them more hygienic for anal play. Silicone, glass, and metal toys are easy to clean with mild soap and water. Some sex toy manufacturers make an antibacterial cleanser for their products, known as toy cleaner. These cleaners come in liquid form, usually in a spray bottle for ease of use. You should always invest in a quality antibacterial toy cleaner for your anal toys.  

Cons

  • Even though some companies advertise their plugs as safe for all day wear, you really shouldn’t keep one inside of you for more than a few hours. Like any muscle, your anus and rectum will get tired after a while. Leaving a toy in for too long can wear out these muscles, causing health problems such as incontinence. While plugs are meant for insertion, you should never leave one in for longer than your session.  

  • Using a toy too big can cause rectal tearing; always err on the side of caution and start small. Any new sexual experience should be taken slowly. The same goes for anal penetration. Choosing a toy that is too big for you and forcing it inside of you when your body is not ready for it will cause harm. It’s always best to start small by using a finger to penetrate yourself and selecting your first toy that is about that size. You can always upgrade if you want more “toy” up there.  

  • Soft and pliable plugs have ingredients that can risk your health. While soft and pliable toys attract many newbies to the anal scene, they are not the best for you. These toys include latex, which may cause an allergic reaction, and phthalates. Phthalates are a chemical compound in most plastics that make them stretch and give them the bendability that you think you’ll like in an anal toy. Actually, phthalates have cancer-causing properties, so they should be avoided at all costs. When selecting your first toy, always choose a model that is explicitly labeled as latex-free and phthalate-free.

Conclusion

Taking the plunge into anal penetration can be an exciting way to spice up your bedroom activities. Butt plugs will enhance your solo or partner play with minimal effort. They are incredibly versatile items that can help you achieve more intense orgasms or train your body for anal sex. With one of these options, you will be well on your way to experiencing anal pleasure.