Whether you are a novice or an expert, anal penetration can enhance your bedroom play. By stimulating the nerves in your rectum, butt plugs are a common choice for every experience level. They are simple to use, and they come in several sizes and materials. You can try different models to find the one that you like the best.
Choosing the right plug for your comfort and experience level can induce eye-rolling pleasure to your solo session or sex with your partner. But, where do you start? Whether you are looking for a beginner’s toy or an upgrade, we’ve reviewed the best butt plugs for every experience level.
Best Butt Plugs Comparison Chart
Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug
Best Butt Plug
Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet Vibrating Butt Plug
Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug
Icicles No. 48 Glass Plug with Flower Base
Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual Glass Butt Plug
Best Glass Butt Plug
Lovehoney Classic Extra Petite Beginner's Butt Plug
Best Butt Plug to
Wear All Day
Cupid's Itty Bitty Beginner's Plug
Best Butt Plug for Women
Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug
Best Prostate Butt Plug
Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager
Best Butt Plug for Men
What is a Butt Plug?
A butt plug is a tapered, cone-shaped toy, with a slender neck and a flared base that slides into your anus. The tapered cone fits inside of you, while your sphincter muscle closes around the neck to hold the toy in place. When the butt plug is completely inserted, the flared base keeps the toy from sliding too far inside of you.
The butt plug is a set-it-and-forget-it anal toy, making it ideal for both solo sessions and use with a partner. Unlike other toys that require constant movement, it remains inside of you. It gently stretches the anal cavity, stimulating the sensitive nerves for enhanced pleasure.
For men, inserting a butt plug can arouse the prostate (the P-spot), leading to more intense orgasms. This process, known as milking the prostate, has many health benefits, such as a lowered risk of inflammation, infection, and cancer. It also contributes to a better mental state, reducing symptoms of depression and anxiety.
For women, using a butt plug during solo play or with a partner puts pressure on the back of the vaginal wall. When using a vaginal toy or having sex with your partner, this extra pressure makes you feel more “filled up” – a turn-on to some women. The extra nerve stimulation also brings on longer, more powerful orgasms.
Types of Butt Plugs
There are several types of butt plugs with a variety of functions, sizes, and materials. Understanding your own body will make your selection that much easier.
- Non-vibrating/Vibrating. Butt plugs come in two forms: vibrating or non-vibrating. Using a small motor powered through a battery pack, vibrating butt plugs provide extra stimulation for the nerves in your rectum. They have several speeds and functions, so you can find the right one that feels good to you.
- Silicone/Glass/Metal. Three options are the best body-safe butt plugs – silicone, glass, or metal. These materials are nonporous, making them more hygienic. They are extremely easy to clean with soap and water or an antibacterial toy cleaner. Always choose a model that is latex-free and phthalate-free. Latex may irritate the skin, and phthalate is plastic with properties that cause cancer. Even if you do not have skin sensitivities, you should still stick with silicone, glass, or metal plugs. They are much better for your body. To add an extra dimension to your anal play, metal and glass hold heat and cold very well, making them great tools for temperature play.
- Size. Butt plugs come in small/petite, medium, or large sizes. When choosing your next toy, you should know what size you feel comfortable with using. If you like the feeling of a finger inside of you, then you should start small. Those more experienced with anal penetration – either with toys or during sexual activity – can start with medium or larger sizes. Some models are inflatable: using a manual pump, these butt plugs inflate to stretch the anal cavity. They are great tools for preparing the body for anal sex.
How to Choose a Butt Plug
Choosing the right butt plug depends on your experience with anal play and the features you enjoy. For men and women just starting anal play, it is best to start small. Several petite butt plugs will provide the stimulation to send you over the edge. Those who are more experienced with anal play will find them plugs too small – you can start with a larger size. Unless you are using a glass or metal toy for temperature play, you should always stick to silicone.
If you like the feeling of being “filled up,” then you should choose…
A non-vibrating silicone butt plug.
If you like the feeling of movement, then you should choose…
If you like to experiment with hot or cool sensations, then you should choose…
A metal or a glass plug.
If you like a finger inside of you during solo sessions or sex with your partner, then you should choose…
A small/petite butt plug.
If you have used other sex toys for anal penetration, then you should choose…
A medium butt plug.
If you enjoy anal sex with your partner, then you should choose…
A large butt plug.
If you are looking to prepare your body for anal sex or double anal penetration, then you should choose…
An inflatable butt plug.
Review of the Best Butt Plugs
Now that you know the different types of butt plugs, you may feel confident in which one you would like to try. But which model is the best? We’ve reviewed the best butt plugs on the market today. We’ve even broken them down into categories, taking the guesswork out of selecting your new favorite toy.
1. Best Butt Plug: Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug
If you are a novice to anal play looking to increase your pleasure, then the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug is the toy for you. Best for beginners who want to dive into intermediate anal player status, this medium butt plug has a silky silicone exterior that pairs well with any water-based lubricant. It is easy to clean with mild soap and water or toy cleaner. At 5” of insertable length and 1.7” diameter, this plug has a defined taper with just the right amount of stretch for beginner to intermediate users.
Waterproof for tub or shower play, the Medium Plug is latex-free and phthalate-free for body-safe play. Although the plug has a firm feel, there is enough flexibility to make insertion more comfortable. The flared base keeps it in place to prevent slipping. This medium plug moves with you, making it perfect for public wear, foreplay, or solo sessions. When you want to move up from penetration with small toys or fingers, then the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug is a must-have.
If you are a novice to anal play looking to increase your pleasure, then the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug is the toy for you. Best for beginners who want to dive into intermediate anal player status, this medium butt plug has a silky silicone exterior that pairs well with any water-based lubricant.
It is easy to clean with mild soap and water or toy cleaner. At 5” of insertable length and 1.7” diameter, this plug has a defined taper with just the right amount of stretch for beginner to intermediate users.
Waterproof for tub or shower play, the Medium Plug is latex-free and phthalate-free for body-safe play. Although the plug has a firm feel, there is enough flexibility to make insertion more comfortable. The flared base keeps it in place to prevent slipping.
This medium plug moves with you, making it perfect for public wear, foreplay, or solo sessions. When you want to move up from penetration with small toys or fingers, then the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug is a must-have.
The Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug is the best upgrade from smaller plugs. With a streamlined design, this tapered plug has a smooth silicone exterior for easy insertion. The elegant and simple design makes the toy simple to use, and clean up is a breeze with soap and water. Although more experienced players may find that it is too small, this toy is ideal for beginners who want to step up their anal play. With its luxurious feel and comfort, the Lovehoney Classic Silicone Medium Plug is our choice for the best butt plug.
2. Best Vibrating Butt Plug: Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet
Small plugs are a great introduction to anal play, and vibrating options can further your pleasure. The Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug is a petite, silicone toy for beginners.
A plug measuring 4” of insertable length and 1.3” thick at the widest point, the Bedtime Bullet has a gentle taper. This helps glide the toy right in when paired with a water-based anal lubricant.
Although the toy is made from body-safe silicone, it isn’t too hard to the touch. It is flexible enough to cater to the shape of your body, improving the feeling of insertion. Once the Bedtime Bullet is inside of you, use the wired controller to sample 7 patterns and 3 speeds of vibration for even more eye-rolling pleasure.
The flared base also doubles as a suction cup, sticking to any smooth, flat surface. Those looking for something different to their anal play without upgrading in size will love the Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug.
The Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet is a small, body-safe toy for the beginner, but it has some design flaws. The wire comes out of the side of the plug (instead of the bottom), which can get in the way while you are using it. Although the controller is very easy to use, the batteries drain quickly (remove them when you aren’t using the toy to conserve power). Overall, the combination of the luxurious feel and the strong vibrations make this an item you shouldn’t miss. It is our pick for the best vibrating butt plug.
3. Best Inflatable Butt Plug: Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug
Some more experienced anal players love the stretch that larger plugs provide. An inflatable butt plug will help you find the right girth that you enjoy, and it is a handy tool for preparing the rectum for anal sex.
The Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug 4.5 Inch is made of a phthalate-free rubber with an attached hand pump and wired vibrator to intensify your anal training. With a flared base and a tapered design, it has the features of other smaller plugs. Squeezing the pump handle will slowly increase the size, delightfully stretching you after insertion.
Using the attached vibrator will stimulate you for a more satisfying experience. With one constant speed that you gradually increase with the scroll wheel, you can find just the right setting. The Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug measures 4.5” of insertable length and 2.86” wide before inflation, so it is for intermediate to experienced users only.
With a thick neck, the plug may be too intense for beginners. With the ability to control the inflation and the vibrations, this toy is entirely customizable, making it a great starter inflatable plug.
Even those with experience in anal play may find it difficult to choose the right size for an upgrade. With the Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug, you can control the strength of the vibrations and the size of the inflation for the best anal experience. The rubber plug contains latex, so those with allergies should choose another option. A great budget-friendly inflating plug that offers the same features as other more expensive selections, the Lovehoney Vibrating Inflatable Butt Plug is a great starter item for men and women who want to try this type of anal play.
4. Best Jeweled Butt Plug: Icicles No 48 Glass Plug with Flower Base
For an upgrade on the traditional butt plug, the Icicles No 48 Glass Plug with Flower Base adds a touch of class to your anal activities. This petite borosilicate glass plug is compatible with any lubricant, and it slides inside of you more smoothly than other anal toys. The toy has a bulb shape with a deep taper that is best for more experienced beginners.
At 3” of insertable length and 1.3” wide, the Icicles No 48 stimulates the most sensitive nerves in the anal cavity for a more fulfilling experience. A flared flower base makes a pleasing sight when it is fully inserted.
The size difference between the bulb and the slender neck make this toy ideal for long-term wear. Your sphincter muscle will naturally hold on to the neck, keeping the toy inserted – no matter how much you move around.
For those new to glass toys, they are harder and heavier than silicone plugs, but they offer a much better experience. Borosilicate glass holds temperature very well, so you can experience with warm or cool sensations for further stimulation. The extra weight of the plug inside of you will give you that “filled up” feeling, making the Icicles No 48 an excellent starter toy for those who want to try all the benefits of a glass plug. Once you use it, you’ll reach for this beautiful plug again and again.
Glass toys tend to turn off some users, even though they are the safest toys you can use. They are shatterproof and hypoallergenic, making them great options for men and women who have skin sensitivities. The Icicles No. 48 is the perfect size for beginners, but intermediate and advanced users may think it is too small.
Great for solo use or with a partner, you can use this plug to introduce temperature play in the bedroom. Finding the ultimate body-safe toy in such a small size is definitely a winner, but the best appeal of the toy is its appearance when it is inserted. The flower base resting against your skin will drive your partner wild. It is our choice for the best jeweled butt plug.
5. Best Beginner Butt Plug: BASICS Slimline Butt Plug
Finding your first butt plug can be overwhelming, and we always recommend starting small. For the smallest and simplest anal toy on the market today, the BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is ideal for newbies who want to explore back-door fun slowly.
With only 4.5” insertable length and 1” wide, this petite plug is the best choice for beginners. The body-safe PVC material is latex-free and phthalate-free, and it makes the plug both firm and flexible for smoother insertion.
Despite this plug’s small size, it has some interesting features of larger plugs. This plug is compatible with either water-based or silicone lubricant, so you can choose the type that works best for you. The flared base has suction so that you can attach the toy to any smooth or flat surface.
The soft material does collect dust, so you should invest in a small storage bag to keep your toy clean for the next use. For a simple yet effective starter plug, the BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is the best beginners’ plug available today.
When it comes to anal play, everyone needs to start somewhere. For the curious starter, the BASICS Slimline Butt Plug is a slender option without an intimidating appearance. It isn’t much thicker than a finger, making it a great step up for beginners to anal toys.
The PVC material is body-safe, but it does require some closer cleaning and care than silicone, metal, or glass options. The BASICS Slimline might slip out of more experienced beginners, but it has a perfect taper for those new to the anal scene.
6. Best Glass Butt Plug: Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual Glass Butt Plug
Most who use a glass plug never go back to any other type of material. They have a smooth feel and a delicate weight for extra pleasure. Glass also holds temperature well, making warm and cool sensations a part of your anal play.
The Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual Glass Butt Plug is a small borosilicate glass plug for beginner to intermediate users. There is a curved taper into the neck for a comfortable glide with any lubricant. At 4” of insertable length and 1.4” width, this glass toy is easy to insert and remove, and it stays in place during activity.
The Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual Glass Plug is a wonderful option for men and women who like the feeling of a small plug, but they want to try a different sensation before upgrading to a larger size. This product is incredibly easy to clean with soap and water, and it comes with its own bag for discreet storage.
The body-safe, latex-free, and phthalate-free Pure Pleasure is ideal for anyone who has skin allergies because it is a completely hypoallergenic item. Although it is a small plug, it has a thicker shape which may intimidate those new to anal play. Perfect for the beginner with moderate experience, the Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual is the best glass plug for anal use.
For a sophisticated upgrade on your small butt plug, the Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual Glass Butt Plug is everything a glass plug should be. The smooth curve of the taper makes insertion a smooth and pleasurable experience, and the glass is excellent for introducing temperature play.
While it won’t be large enough for intermediate to advanced users, the Pure Pleasure is a great glass plug for beginners to anal play. The base isn’t as large as other plugs you may have used in the past, but that doesn’t take away from its function. It firmly stays in place, no matter how much you move. The Lovehoney Pure Pleasure Sensual Glass Butt Plug is a winner for anyone’s toy collection.
7. Best Butt Plug to Wear All Day: Lovehoney Classic Extra Petite Beginner's Butt Plug
One of the most exciting adventures in anal pleasure is finding a plug that you can wear during your daily activities. You can seduce your partner or give yourself an extra thrill while doing the dishes or running errands.
The Lovehoney Classic Extra Petite Beginner’s Butt Plug is the size of a pinky, so it is the perfect size for all-day wear. It measures 2.75” of insertable length and about an inch thick, so it slides in comfortably while allowing for movement. With an extra flared base for secure placement, the Classic Extra Petite will send thrills up your spine as you walk around with it inside of you.
The body-safe silicone material has a smooth matte finish, and it is latex-free and phthalate-free for hypoallergenic use. This material cleans easily with soap and water or toy cleaner, so you can keep it handy for your next public adventure. While the size is ideal for those who want to try hands-free anal penetration before investing in a small butt plug, its design is better for anal newbies.
Those with more experience than the tip of a finger might be disappointed. Since the flared base can make vaginal play or other sexual stimulation tricky, the Lovehoney Classic Extra Petite Beginner’s Butt Plug is best for solo use. Its discreet size and comfort make it the perfect option for a butt plug you can wear all day.
If you’re shopping for a starter plug and wished there was a smaller ”petite” plug, then the Lovehoney Classic Extra Petite Beginner’s Butt Plug is the perfect size for you. Measuring no larger than a finger, this toy isn’t intimidating to those new to using plugs. The size is ideal for extended wear, so you can leave this toy inside of you all day long. Although your body will quickly become used to the shape, the Lovehoney Classic Extra Petite Beginner’s Butt Plug is a great introduction to anal penetration.
8. Best Butt Plug for Women: Cupid's Itty Bitty Beginner's Plug
As much as we don’t want to admit it, women will judge a toy on its appearance as much as its function. Most butt plugs come in standard cone-shape sizes, with a decidedly masculine appearance. For a more aesthetically pleasing option, the Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug is the perfect size for women who are new to anal play.
This teardrop-shaped silicone plug with a tapered design keeps it in place for extended wear during solo sessions or use with your partner. The material is latex-free and phthalate-free, so women who need a body-safe toy will love it.
The Cupid is easy to clean with soap and water, and the smooth surface combined with a water-based anal lubricant helps the toy slide inside of you without resistance. A convenient anchor hook at the base makes the Cupid easy to insert and remove for a more comfortable experience.
With only 2” of insertable length and 1” diameter, the Cupid Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug isn’t intimidating for women who have never used a plug before. It is perfectly shaped for a woman’s body: the plug is thicker where there are more nerves, so the design provides maximum anal pleasure in women. The Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug is the best butt plug for women who want to test out anal play.
Most women automatically shut down when their partner suggests anal play. For the ultimate starter item, the Cupid’s Itty Bitty Beginner’s Plug has a beautiful appearance that makes anal play less intimidating. With a quality design that caters to a woman’s body, the Cupid slides in easily, putting pressure on your most sensitive nerves for an exhilarating experience.
The plug is so small that it might slip out during your orgasm, depending on how tight your muscles clench. Overall, this well-designed toy with a body-safe material makes it the perfect choice for women new to anal penetration.
9. Best Prostate Butt Plug: Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug
Anal penetration is the best way for men to have a prostate orgasm. This full-body experience tops all other orgasms if you dare to try it. The Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug has a perfect curve for massaging the prostate, and the ergonomic design makes it simple to use.
With a reverse taper, the Booty Buddy remains in place, gliding in smoothly with water-based anal lubricant. At 4” insertable length and 1” diameter, the size isn’t intimidating for those new to prostate massagers.
The Booty Buddy is very soft to the touch for more comfortable wear. It is latex-free and phthalate-free for body-safe play, and it is ideal for long-term wear. The flared anchor base keeps the massager firmly in place during activity.
While it may be too small for those experienced with prostate massagers, the Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug is the perfect size for men who want a quality starter toy to explore prostate stimulation.
The Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug is a wonderful introduction to the experience of prostate massage. With a body-safe material, the toy is specifically designed to fit your body. The natural curve and reversed taper stimulates your rectal muscles to contract to hold it in place to massage your prostate every time.
Although most massagers can double as G-spot stimulators for women, this toy is best for men. While you can use it with a partner, you might want to keep this gem to yourself. The Booty Buddy is a great starter item that offers the same stimulation as more expensive models.
10. Best Butt Plug for Men: Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager
If you enjoy a good prostate massage, you’ll need a hands-free toy that will provide excellent stimulation. The body-safe silicone Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager is one of the most elite designs available today. Latex-free and phthalate-free, this waterproof double-sided massager gently stimulates both the prostate and the perineum for an exquisite experience.
Although the size is best for beginners to intermediate users, the targeted design provides excellent stimulation for men with advanced practice. Ergonomically shaped to hit your prostate every time, the reverse taper encourages your body to hold the toy in place for hands-free fun.
The Desire Luxury is USB-rechargeable for eco-friendly use, boasting 8 functions and 12 speeds of powerful vibration for the most intense stimulation. The wireless remote has a 25-foot range: hand your partner the controller for extra fun, or keep the remote next to you during your solo session.
This travel-friendly massager is great on the road: it has a case for discreet storage and a lock to keep it from turning on in your bag. For men looking for an upgrade on their basic prostate massager, the Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager is a luxurious take on the standard design.
If you have tried a prostate massager and you are looking to step up your pleasure, the Desire Luxury Rechargeable Remote Control Prostate Massager is perfect for you. The silicone is easy to clean and body-safe for the ultimate experience. The strength of the vibrations and the hands-free design will make this toy your go-to prostate massager. Although it runs high on the price point, the toy’s comfort and ease of use make it worth the money.
Butt plugs are the best toy to use for anal penetration. They have a simple construction to maximize pleasure, and they come in a variety of models and designs to suit your needs. When using a toy for solo play, you should select an option that you feel comfortable with using on a regular basis.
If you want to include a partner, look at the different options together to see what you would like. Anal penetration adds a different dimension to the sexual experience, and the right plug can bring you sessions to new heights.